Parents call school discipline 'excessive'

Parents call school discipline 'excessive'

Story Video: Click here

MARTIN COUNTY, Fla. -- Some Martin County parents and community members are preparing to protest the Martin County School District, claiming a disciplinary board is imposing “excessive” punishments.

Now, they want the district to take a second look at the school's discipline policies.

It centers around four 8th-grade students at Stuart Middle School who were given ten days suspension and transferred to Spectrum, an alternate school in the district.

The students were first-time disciplinary offenders, and honor students.

Erica Tucker says her daughter was one of the children given the punishment.

Her daughter, Ruby, explained one of her friends brought an unusual item to the lunch table in late November.

"One of my friends pulled out a travel-size, unmarked, clear spray bottle with clear liquid in it. I didn't assume there was alcohol in there."

But, there was alcohol inside.

Ruby explained her friend passed it to another girl at the table. Eventually, she says the spray bottle got to her and someone told her to spray it in her mouth.

"This is obviously my big mistake, I took it and I sprayed it in my mouth," Ruby said.

She said the taste made her run to the water fountain and spit out the alcohol. At that point, she wasn't quite sure what she had put in her mouth.

The next day, she says her friend was not at school and she was called to the office.

That's when Ruby found out what she consumed, and learned she would be facing punishment.

"Of course I was upset with what happened," Erica Tucker said.

Tucker said she punished Ruby at home for carelessly consuming something unknown.

But, Tucker says the punishment being imposed by the district is going too far.

Ruby was suspended for ten days and will have to finish the rest of her 8th grade year at Spectrum.

"I feel that is for children who are repeat offenders and have been in trouble multiple times. I really was shocked," Erica Tucker said.

However, district leaders tell WPTV they were simply following policies in place related to alcohol.

Alcohol does not fall under the school's zero tolerance policy, and Tucker believes the punishment should not be 'one size fits all'.

Tucker is concerned she was not given a chance to appeal her daughter's discipline, saying she could not appeal to the disciplinary board because her daughter was not being expelled.

She also says she has not been able to view a video where her daughter is allegedly seen running to the water fountain.

She also believes there should be a sliding scale for the punishment given depending on the severity of the infraction.

"She was mandated the same punishment as the person who decided to bring alcohol into school," Tucker said.

Now, Ruby and the other students punished will not graduate with their 8th grade class.

Ruby hopes she will still be well prepared for high school.

"I think they're failing some really good children," Tucker said.

Two protests are planned outside the Martin County School District building Tuesday.

The first between 8 AM and 8:30 a.m. There will be a second protest at 3:40 p.m.

Scripps Only Content 2017